6/04/2026

ROBERT MITCHUM BUSTING ROBERT RYAN THROUGH 'THE RACKET'

Joyce Mackenzie and Robert Mitchum in THE RACKET Year: 1951 Rating: ***1/2

Based on a let's-fight-city-corruption picture from 1928, and remade to center on a then-current anti-mafia-probe, it's no wonder that RKO's THE RACKET plays out so deliberately over-the-top, where Robert Ryan not only openly admits to being the head of an illegal/totally corrupt syndicate, but shoots and kills an honest lawman right inside a police station... with a cub reporter witness only inches away...

In that, Ryan gets most of the praise for a performance that's more 1930's teeth-clenching gangbusters than subtle 1950's noir, which, for the lack of alleyway shadows and femme fatales, many claim this feature as being something other than...

Robert Mitchum and Robert Ryan in THE RACKET

Which is an ongoing/never-ending debate on any b-crimer that isn't dreamily melodramatic the likes of OUT OF THE PAST... segwaying into the other Robert here in Robert Mitchum, the star of several Howard Hughes productions, where, on the heels of playing likable losers in THIS KIND OF WOMAN and THE BIG STEAL, this is his most solidly straightforward performance...

As a police chief the syndicate moves around in order to never press permanent charges, and with scene-stealing/ideal-driven good cop William Talman by his side, Mitchum doesn't simply breeze around with his handsome slow-burn cool, but really fits the part with both feet planted firmly on the ground... 

Robert Mitchum and Robert Ryan in THE RACKET

The biggest problem (besides pretty Lizabeth Scott in a throwaway nightclub canary/dame role) is that everything's too up-front, particularly with Ryan's scrunched-up mug exploding into temper-tantrums....

In one reaction shot, Mitchum seems to intentionally smirk at Ryan's overacting: playing more of a head gangster's viciously lethal thug than any kind of realistic big boss, making THE RACKET more a good vs evil fable than either noir or your typical standard detective story.

Robert Mitchum and Robert Ryan in THE RACKET
Ray Collins in THE RACKET
Robert Ryan in THE RACKET
William Talman and Virginia Huston in THE RACKET
Virginia Huston in THE RACKET
From THE RACKET
William Conrad in THE RACKET
William Talman in THE RACKET
William Conrad in THE RACKET
Lizabeth Scott and Robert Hutton in THE RACKET
Joyce Mackenzie and Robert Mitchum in THE RACKET




No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.